Middle Torch Key Homes for Sale

Welcome to Middle Torch Key, a hidden gem in the heart of Florida's stunning Florida Keys. Nestled within Monroe County, this idyllic island offers a unique blend of natural beauty, tranquility, and vibrant local culture. As part of the renowned Florida Keys, Middle Torch Key is surrounded by crystal-clear waters, lush tropical landscapes, and breathtaking sunsets that will leave you in awe.

For those seeking a slice of paradise, Middle Torch Key presents an array of homes for sale that cater to a variety of lifestyles. Whether you’re looking for a cozy waterfront cottage, a luxurious estate with panoramic ocean views, or a charming bungalow tucked away in a serene setting, this island has something for everyone. Many properties feature private docks, allowing for easy access to world-class fishing, boating, and snorkeling in the surrounding waters.

Living in Middle Torch Key means embracing a laid-back lifestyle where outdoor adventures await at every turn. Explore the nearby nature reserves, indulge in fresh seafood at local eateries, or simply relax on your porch as you soak in the island’s captivating atmosphere. The community here is welcoming and tight-knit, making it easy to feel right at home.

With homes for sale in this enchanting locale, now is the perfect time to invest in your dream property on Middle Torch Key. Experience the unparalleled beauty and charm of island living — your slice of paradise awaits!

Newest Middle Torch Key Homes for Sale

$689,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 620565 MLS

Imagine having the freedom to create your own secluded retreat in the heart of the Lower Florida Keys. This remarkable offering includes two adjacent 2.5-acre parcels, combining for approximately 5 acres--an exceptionally rare amount of land in the Florida Keys. Existing improvements include two separate residences, each offering one bedroom and one bathroom. One parcel is improved with a single-family home, while the other features a manufactured home. Both properties have established electric service and are connected to the sewer system, making them immediately usable while you plan for the future. The parcel at 2231 Middle Torch Road includes a ROGO allocation, creating an outstanding opportunity to construct a new home. Conceptual renderings have already been prepared to showcase one possible vision, but the possibilities are yours to define. Whether your goal is a peaceful island getaway, a private homestead surrounded by nature, or a property designed for generations to enjoy together, the setting provides the space and flexibility to bring those ideas to life. Spend your days boating the turquoise waters of the Lower Keys from a nearby private boat launch, then return home to the quiet beauty of native vegetation, abundant wildlife, and the iconic Key deer that call this area home. Opportunities to own five contiguous acres in the Florida Keys are exceptionally scarce. Combining privacy, natural beauty, and future development potential, this one-of-a-kind property offers the chance to create something truly special in one of the Keys' most unique settings.

2231 Middle Torch Rd, Middle Torch

$1,800,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 607483 MLS

Gorgeous Open Water home that has been beautifully remodeled on 1.65 Acres of private land with handicap accessibilty! Complete remodel done, including the concrete pilings completed by a licensed contractor. Huge downstairs enclosure with a 2-car garage, this is an incredible opportunity to own a piece of nature in the Florida Keys! Privacy abounds on 1.65 acres of beautifully preserved, natural habitat, nestled on the open water with great boating and amazing views from every room in the house! Completely remodeled, this 3 bedroom 2 bathroom home has clean lines and architecturally gorgeous open concept living. Stainless steel appliances, quartz countertops, pantry, breakfast nook, bar area, open dining room, several seating areas, fireplace and gorgeous views from all angles! This home has handicap accessibility including a new full-size elevator, custom master en-suite and open floor plan for easy access. Impact widows and doors, 2-car garage, 20,000 gallon cistern (with public water available if you would like), large storage/entertaining area, path to the dock that has Ipe wood and a 3,000 pound boat lift that can be upgraded to your needs... all on the open water. Great boating access to the gulf or ocean. Owner has repaired columns, trimmed trees to open up the view and is connected to public sewer. This house is truly unique and just waiting for its new owner! Property is virtually staged. Nature Lovers Paradise!

3127 Stewart Rd, Middle Torch

Start Your Search