Sugarloaf Key Homes under $3 million

Sugarloaf Key Homes under $3 million

Welcome to Sugarloaf Key, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the Florida Keys, where the sun kisses the turquoise waters and the gentle breezes whisper tales of island life. Located in Monroe County, this charming island community offers a perfect blend of tranquility and adventure, making it an ideal destination for those seeking a slice of paradise.

Sugarloaf Key is renowned for its stunning natural beauty, featuring lush landscapes, vibrant wildlife, and breathtaking waterfront views. Whether you're an avid fisherman, a boating enthusiast, or simply someone who enjoys peaceful walks along the shore, this island has something for everyone. The nearby Sugarloaf Sanctuary is a haven for birdwatchers and nature lovers, showcasing the unique flora and fauna of the region.

For those looking to call Sugarloaf Key home, you'll find an array of beautiful properties available for under $3 million. These homes often boast expansive views, spacious layouts, and access to the serene waters of the Florida Keys. Imagine waking up to the sound of waves lapping against the shore and enjoying your morning coffee on a sun-drenched patio, surrounded by palm trees and the sweet scent of saltwater.

With its laid-back lifestyle, friendly community, and proximity to Key West's vibrant culture and nightlife, Sugarloaf Key offers a unique opportunity to experience the best of island living. Whether you're searching for a vacation retreat or a permanent residence, Sugarloaf Key's real estate market has something special waiting for you. Discover the magic of this enchanting island and make it your own!

Newest Sugarloaf Key Homes under $3 million

17134 Buttonwood Dr, Sugarloaf
$1,985,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 622059 MLS
Exceptional Waterfront Living in Sugarloaf Shores! Discover coastal elegance and relaxed island living in this beautifully appointed Glenn Gray-designed, 3-bedroom, 3-bath retreat. Lush, mature tropical landscaping creates a private setting, complemented by a spacious semicircular driveway, abundant off-street parking, and covered parking on both sides of the home. Inside, an expansive open floor plan seamlessly connects the great room, dining area, and inviting kitchen featuring granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a generous island. Travertine flooring and plantation shutters add timeless coastal charm. The desirable split-bedroom design provides privacy for owners and guests alike. The primary suite features a walk-in closet, beautifully finished bath, and direct access to the screened waterfront porch. Across the home, a second ensuite bedroom and versatile third bedroom, currently used as an office with built-ins, offer welcoming accommodations. French doors open to a spacious screened porch with tropical ceiling fans and picturesque canal views. Additional doors access the elevated wraparound walkway, with stairs leading to a heated pool and inviting outdoor gathering areas. Boaters will appreciate approximately 125 feet of concrete dockage on a roughly 60-foot-wide canal, dockside water and electric, a 20,000-pound boat lift, and davits. The most direct route to open water passes beneath the fixed Sugarloaf Boulevard Bridge; reported clearance is approximately 10 feet, subject to tides and verification. From peaceful mornings on the porch to afternoons on the water, this is Florida Keys living at its finest. Your own piece of paradise awaits!

17134 Buttonwood Dr, Sugarloaf

265 S Point Dr, Sugarloaf
$2,549,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 621772 MLS
Exceptional waterfront living in prestigious Sugarloaf Shores! Built in 2020, this stunning 4-bedroom, 3-bath home offers breathtaking open water views, spectacular sunrises, and the perfect blend of coastal elegance and Florida Keys living. Thoughtfully designed with 2,594 square feet of living space, this beautiful home features a spacious open floor plan, split-bedroom layout, and two additional bonus rooms with the potential for extra bedrooms, offering flexibility for family and guests. The inviting living and dining areas flow seamlessly into a gorgeous kitchen featuring stainless steel appliances, generous counter space, and plenty of room for entertaining. The spacious primary suite offers a walk-in closet and a beautifully appointed bathroom complete with a soaking tub and separate walk-in shower. Step outside onto the covered porch and take in the breathtaking sunrise views overlooking the sparkling open water. Enjoy your own private waterfront retreat, complete with a saltwater swimming pool, concrete dock, and boat lift, making it easy to embrace the boating and outdoor lifestyle the Florida Keys are known for. Elevated construction provides an expansive ground-level area featuring covered parking, two separate storage rooms, and a spacious concrete-finished outdoor living and entertainment area with plenty of room to relax, gather, and enjoy the tropical surroundings. Additional features include hurricane-impact windows and doors, Hardie board siding, and a fully fenced property. Located just 15 minutes from Key West, this exceptional Sugarloaf Shores property offers the beauty of peaceful waterfront living with convenient access to everything the Lower Florida Keys have to offer. Whether you're enjoying your morning coffee as the sun rises over the water, spending the day boating, or relaxing poolside, this home truly captures the Florida Keys lifestyle!

265 S Point Dr, Sugarloaf

17155 W Hibiscus Ln, Sugarloaf
$949,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 621720 MLS
WATERFRONT PARADISE IN THE MAKING! TROPICAL TREASURE & ENDLESS POSSIBILITIES! Some properties have potential but this one already has paradise written all over it! Discover an exceptional waterfront opportunity in beautiful Sugarloaf Key, where wide, deep, swimmable canals, outstanding boating opportunities, and picturesque partial open-water views of Sugarloaf Bay set the stage for the ultimate Florida Keys lifestyle! Nestled on a generously sized lot surrounded by lush, mature tropical vegetation, this property offers a wonderful sense of privacy, natural beauty, and peaceful island living. Located in a wonderful neighborhood with palm-tree-lined sidewalks, it's the perfect setting for leisurely strolls, tropical breezes, and enjoying the relaxed Keys atmosphere. Boating enthusiasts will appreciate the spacious, deep-water canal, with access to both back country boating and Ocean side! While nature lovers will fall in love with the beautiful greenery, tranquil waterfront setting, and inviting waters right outside their door. The home offers an exciting opportunity for renovation, allowing buyers to create their own spectacular coastal retreat while enjoying the many desirable features this property already provides. Exterior is done in concrete board and newly painted with new composite decking. Solar System paid for with low electric bills! Just Imagine adding a sparkling resort-style pool, a fabulous tiki hut for entertaining, and a boat lift to complete your waterfront oasis! Whether you're an investor seeking a value-add opportunity or a buyer dreaming of a personalized island escape, the combination of beautiful waterfront surroundings, exceptional boating, privacy, and neighborhood charm makes this property truly special. The location is captivating, the waterfront is incredible, and the possibilities are endless! Bring your imagination and transform this tropical treasure into your own piece of Keys paradise in the desirable and in demand Sugarloaf Key!

17155 W Hibiscus Ln, Sugarloaf

19543 Navajo St, Sugarloaf
$739,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 620391 MLS
Experience the best in Florida Keys living in this beautifully maintained, elevated 3-bed, 2-bath home, built in 2018 with storm-resistant construction and engineered to withstand winds up to 180 mph. Designed with both durability and comfort in mind, this tropical Keys home offers the peace of mind of newer construction alongside a bright, spacious, open-concept floor plan. Inside, you'll find a gorgeous kitchen featuring abundant white cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, and a large center island overlooking the inviting living area. Stylish finishes throughout include wood-look tile plank flooring, crown molding, 9-foot ceilings, recessed lighting, and ceiling fans throughout the home. The spacious primary suite features a private en-suite bathroom with dual vanities and a generous walk-in, custom built closet system. Two additional bedrooms and a full guest bathroom provide flexibility for family, guests, or a home office. A dedicated laundry room and tankless water heater add everyday convenience. A standout feature of this property is its newer downstairs enclosure, providing substantial additional storage space. Perfect for boating and fishing equipment, outdoor gear, tools, and more. This valuable improvement adds exceptional functionality to the property. Enjoy the island breezes from the large covered upstairs porch, conveniently accessible from the main living area. With fencing on three sides, generous space beneath the elevated home for cars, boats and trailers. With a neighborhood boat ramp just one street away, this property is ideally suited for the Florida Keys lifestyle. Located less than a mile from Sugarloaf School, with convenient access to Key West and nearby military bases, this home offers an exceptional combination of modern construction, impact windows, concrete board siding, practical storage, and multi-island convenience. Built for coastal living and designed for comfort. This house is ready for you to call home!

19543 Navajo St, Sugarloaf

17286 Jamaica Ln, Sugarloaf
$1,200,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 619901 MLS
Just a short boat ride to popular Lower Keys sandbars, coral heads, and fishing grounds, this Sugarloaf Shores canal-front home is made for the buyer who wants boating, fishing, and the easygoing Keys lifestyle right at their doorstep. Set on a quiet street just 15 minutes from Key West, this sturdy concrete 2 bedroom, 2 bath home offers southern exposure overlooking the canal, quick access to open water, and inviting outdoor spaces designed for relaxing after a day on the water. Spend mornings on the screened porch, enjoy afternoon breezes from the private balcony off the primary bedroom, and make the most of a waterfront setting that brings the best of island living together in one place. Inside, the home features an open floor plan with tile floors, high ceilings, a bright living and dining area, and a kitchen with a breakfast bar. The main bedroom includes a walk-in closet and direct balcony access, creating a private spot to enjoy the tropical surroundings. Outside, boaters and water lovers will appreciate the approximately 40-foot dock, dedicated skiff launch/ramp, canal frontage, and quick route to open water. The dock and waterfront setup provide a convenient place to keep a boat, launch a skiff, or head out for a day on the water with ease. The property also offers a garage and carport area, giving plenty of room for parking, storage, and Keys gear. Located in Sugarloaf Shores, this home offers peaceful island living with convenient access to dining, entertainment, and world-class recreation in nearby Key West.

17286 Jamaica Ln, Sugarloaf

Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!